another book on the subject is "The rise and fall of the
graeco-bactrian kingdom" by H. sidky, published by abd publishers,
isbn 51-89011-33-2, 2004
a history of the kingdom including the indian conquests, illustrated
with photos of many coins and some ruins. there is an extensive 38
page bibliography covering bactria and alexander the great.
i was able to obtain it through an internet book dealer
--- In DBMMlist@yahoogroups.com, "Jim Webster" <jim@...> wrote:
>
>
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Steve Burt" <steve.and.mary.burt@...>
> To: <DBMMlist@yahoogroups.com>
> Sent: Friday, May 30, 2008 2:28 PM
> Subject: Re: [DBMMlist] Re: revision of lists 1 - 50,15/5/08.
>
>
>
> >> I didn't - because I know sod all about Bactrians and, having been
> >> assured that Tarn is astoundingly dull, will stay that way :)
> >
> > Narain 'The Indo-Greeks' is more readable. Also much shorter (the
> > book, not the author).
> >
> to quote from an article I did for slingshot
>
> In English, there are four modern authors who have written on these
> kingdoms.
>
>
>
> Bactria, the history of a forgotten Empire. By H.G.Rawlinson. First
> published in 1912, it is obviously dated, much evidence has appeared
since
> it was written, but the author was well travelled and knew at least
part of
> the area personally.
>
>
>
> The Greeks in Bactria & India. W.W.Tarn. Posthumously revised 3rd
edition
> 1997. Interestingly Frank L Holt did the preface. Tarn was one of
the great
> Hellenistic scholars, and he wrote the book as the history of a great
> Hellenistic kingdom on a par with the Seleucids and Ptolemaic Egypt.
He tied
> the history in with Seleucid history, linked the Bactrian kings to the
> Seleucid royal house, and when considering Bactrian conquests in India
> basically seems to have read the sources as to give the kingdom its'
widest
> extent.
>
>
>
> The Indo-Greeks. A.K.Narain.
>
> Originally written in 1957 Narain wrote from an Indian perspective.
Hence he
> stressed Indian connections, and read the sources to limit the Greek
> conquests to the minimum extent. There are places where he agrees
with Tarn
> and places where he stands in awed admiration at the courage of Tarns'
> scholarship.
>
>
>
> Into the Land of Bones, Alexander the Great in Afghanistan. Also
Thundering
> Zeus, the making of Hellenistic Bactria. Both by Frank L Holt, 2005.
>
> Obviously a more modern account, Holt concentrates more on Bactria
than on
> the Indian conquests. In the 'Land of Bones' he also writes as an
American
> for Americans, comparing and contrasting US experience in
Afghanistan with
> Alexander's experience.
>
> He points out that there were an inordinate number of Greek kings,
forty of
> them, to rule between them no more than 250 years. For comparison, and
> depending on exactly how you count them, there were 15 Ptolemy's to
cover a
> similar period. Holt sees these Kings as proto-Afghan warlords,
fighting
> amongst themselves and occasionally being combined by a strong leader.
>
Comments (0)
You don't have permission to comment on this page.